Skip to content

Our People
Our Board
Our Partners
Our History

Member Directory
Find the local products or services you need from our Member Community

Member-to-Member OffersNEW
Check-out our exclusive offers for your business.

Advertise or Partner with usGROW
Improve brand visibility, grow your network and support our business community.

Our News
News, press releases and updates from Business Canterbury.

Bold Company
For what’s happening in the Canterbury business community.

HR Insights
Updates on HR and ER from our resident experts.

Manufacturing & Global Trade Bulletin Industry info for our Canterbury Manufacturers, Importers and Exporters.

RGB_Bold Company_Verticle_WhiteText

podcast.E2.700x450

Listen to some amazng business owners as they share their learnings, challenges and more on The Bold Company podcast, from Business Canterbury.

Business Advocacy
Championing our members’ views on policies and decisions at local and national levels so your voice can be heard.

Business Growth
Providing our members with experts who have the right knowledge, resources and contacts to help your business grow.


Contact us today to see how we can help.

Human Resources
Practical HR/ER support, expert advice, and customised training for your workplace.

Manufacturing
Driving innovation and success for manufacturers across Canterbury.

Global Trade
Supporting members to navigate and thrive in the international marketplace.

Export Documentation Services
Comprehensive Export Documentation Support

PREPARE FOR THE EVOLUTION (Presentation (169)) (5)

Learn how membership with Business Canterbury can help you take your business in the direction you want it to go. 

Standard Memberships

Connect Membership
Build your network and access a range of exclusive member benefits

Thrive Membership
Take your business further with enhanced support and expert guidance.

Invest Membership
Shaping the business landscape through premier support and business advocacy.

Lite Subscription
A taste of what we can offer you.

More Options

Manufacturing Membership
Backing Canterbury Manufacturers

Global Trade Membership
Developed for Importers and Exporters

HR Advice Membership
Expert HR Support When You Need It

HR Premium Membership
Expert Support at the Highest Level

WHAT IS CANTERBURY TRUSTED?

Canterbury Trusted recognises business excellence across our region, as awarded by Business Canterbury.

Why choose a Canterbury Trusted brand

LEARN MORE

About Canterbury Trusted
Differentiate yourself from your competitors.

Frequently Asked Questions
Contact Us

BlogHero.1024x51.QCBS.Aug23

ABOUT ADVOCACY

Our advocacy work programme ensures our members’ views are represented on policies and decisions at a local and national level.

LEARN MORE 

Grow knowledge, build capability and make connections through our events and learning opportunities.

No one does networking like Business Canterbury. Check out our events designed to engage, inform and help you expand your network.

Visit our Eventbrite page to

ExportBF.June2025.600x300b

DON'T MISS

Export Breakfast: Connecting Canterbury to the World HOT

THU 14 AUG: ​Stay ahead of global trade shifts with insights from Air New Zealand Cargo and local exporters.

Michael PriskAug 1, 2025 9:39:43 AM3 min read

Case Law Alert: When a Restructure Isn’t Really a Restructure

Restructure Gone Wrong: Lessons from Callen v Alaron

The recent case of Callen v Alaron Products Ltd [[2025] NZERA 165; 19/03/25; D Beck] highlights the importance of employer not having an ulterior motive or hidden agenda when initiating a restructure.

 

Background

A restructure, or retaliation?

Mr Callen was employed by Alaron Products Ltd (Alaron) in their maintenance department from 25 June 2018 until his employment was terminated on 23 May 2023 as a result of a restructuring process. While this is also about a bullying claim, I will focus on the restructure aspects.

Prior to the restructure, in June 2022, Mr Callen raised a complaint about his immediate manager, believing he was not resolving a safety matter relating to a forklift operator. Mr Callen claimed that after he made his complaint, the manager began to treat him differently and effectively ostracised him. In April 2023, Alaron commenced a change proposal. Mr Callen’s role was placed in a group of four roles, and the proposal was for one of those roles to be disestablished.

On 15 May 2023, the decision to disestablish Mr Callen’s role was confirmed. Around that time, the employment relationship was showing strain. Mr Callen submitted a personal grievance claim of bullying against his manager

Mr Callen applied for one of the maintenance support roles. However, he was unsuccessful. Despite Alaron claiming the change proposal was to enhance skills across the team, the criteria Mr Callen was assessed against was largely character-based. He did not apply for the other two roles as he did not have the requisite ten years’ experience. Alaron said it would not have offered him one of those roles because of the personality clashes with his manager.

The Employment Relations Authority (ERA) found the restructure process gave the appearance of having a sound basis and run in a fair manner. However, the ERA found enough evidence to conclude an ulterior motive at play. Alaron had grouped together Mr Callen along with three of his colleagues without any analysis of what their roles were and without regard to group dynamics. The role Mr Callen applied for was essentially the same as his existing role and no explanation offered about not appointing into that new role.

The ERA found Alaron had not genuinely considered redeployment options. Alaron wanted to end the relationship with Mr Callen not because his position was genuinely surplus or his skills were redundant to their needs, but because Mr Callen had displayed behaviour that made the relationship between him and his immediate manager deeply problematic.

 

Decision

When process isn't enough

The Employment Relations Authority found two major procedural defects with the restructure proposal.

  1. The Employment Relations Authority (ERA) found the restructure process gave the appearance of having a sound basis and run in a fair manner. However, the ERA found enough evidence to conclude an ulterior motive at play. Alaron grouped together Mr Callen along with three colleagues without any analysis of what their roles were and without regard to group dynamics. The role Mr Callen applied for was essentially the same as his existing role and no explanation offered about not appointing him into that new role.
  2. ERA found Alaron had not genuinely considered redeployment or options. Alaron wanted to end the relationship with Mr Callen not because his position was genuinely surplus or his skills were redundant to their needs, but because Mr Callen had displayed behaviour that made the relationship between him and his immediate manager deeply problematic.

The Authority found Mr Callen dismissal was unjustified. It awarded him $14,820 in lost wages and $20,000 compensation for hurt and humiliation in relation to the unjustified dismissal only .

 

Key Takeaways

Redundancy must be real

  • Employers should only carry out restructure for genuine commercial reasons and not have ‘hidden agendas’ and use this process to get rid of employees that have problems with
  • Selection Criteria in restructure proposal should be objective or evidence based rather than subjective criteria such as character or interpersonal fit
  • Employers are required to genuinely consider redeployment and/or retraining options before selecting employees for redundancy.

 

Conclusion

A costly reminder

This case is a clear reminder that even well-documented processes won’t protect employers if the underlying intent isn’t genuine. Restructures must be based on business needs—not personal conflicts.

 


We can help

For more information, refer the article and advice under Case Law. For specialist advice in this area, please contact me at michaelp@cecc.org.nz.

avatar
Michael Prisk
HR/ER Business Consultant
I’m passionate about helping businesses build healthy, supportive workplaces where people thrive. From offering practical HR consultancy to running training sessions and sharing insights through blogs, I’m here to make HR simple and effective for our members.

RELATED ARTICLES